Content without a shape

I've been listening to articles more than reading them lately. I'm not sure why that is. But at some point the reading mode started feeling like more effort than it needed to be.

When I read, I can see the shape of an argument before I'm inside it. Scan the length, catch a phrase in the third paragraph, decide how much attention it deserves. It feels like being on the bank, watching the current. With voice I'm in the water from the first sentence. No pre-evaluation. I committed the moment it started.

That felt like the key difference, and also somewhat a loss of control.

If screens eventually disappear (this is a thought experiment, not a prediction) voice becomes the interface. That's already imaginable. But then there's smell. A device that emits scent doesn't compete for my visual attention; it bypasses evaluation entirely. That's like walking past the bakery and I'm already hungry before I've decided anything. Translating that to the imaginary device, a travel piece could carry ocean salt, and a wine review could emit that particular wine scent. Content that works on me before I've consented to engage with it.

Reading gave me control over pace and a fixed object to disagree with. Listening puts me in the current. Smell removes the pause between stimulus and response entirly.

Then I thought about conversation. An actual back-and-forth, fluid, interruptible, responsive. I can push back mid-sentence, redirect the whole thing. And the content doesn't exist in fixed form without me in it.

We're already partway there. When I ask an AI to edit a paragraph, I'm not making a direct change; I'm describing an intention and watching something regenerate around it. With images it goes further: describe what I want and it rebuilds the whole thing, often with twists I didn't ask for. The kind of control I have in a word processor, where I change exactly this word and move exactly that element, is already loosening. I'm describing direction, not making edits.

That's where the static comparison breaks down completely. Everything we know about publishing assumes a document: something with a shape, a beginning and end, a version we can share. Conversation isn't that. It's a different.

For anyone making content for a living, that's strange to sit with. You're not issuing articles anymore. You're training a voice that participates in conversations on your behalf, responding differently each time, to each person. The visual toolkit, logo, typography, photography, all of it collapses when there's no screen. But the fixed document collapses too. What remains is something more like character. A way of reasoning. A set of positions.

This post argued that clean, structured content outlasts whatever interface gets built around it. RSS proved it. Agents are proving it again. But that assumed content was still a fixed thing underneath, just more portable.

I can't answer what happens when content stops being a fixed thing.

I find it strange and genuinely interesting. I don't know where it goes from here.


Personal writing on software, building products, travel, and life on Madeira.
Honest, infrequent, not optimized for your inbox.



2026

Content without a shape


29/04

Complicated vs Complex


28/04

The End of the Cross-Platform Compromise


27/04

No Dashboard, No Excuses


26/04

The attention economy proved RSS right


25/04

The Quality Drift


24/04

The Developer Role is Changing


22/04

2024

My future self knows better


19/12

All or nothing


18/12

Social following & connection


08/12

My relationship to social media


01/12

Dental surgery & expectations


22/11

On leaving X again


08/11

Personal blogs


02/11

Click to cancel


19/10

2021

Every day learning


30/01

Out of the shadow


10/01

Now vs. Later


09/01

Why do I want to write


08/01

Our first Youtube LIVE


02/01

A new day


01/01

2020

Daily Practice


30/12

Fast forward six months


12/12

Going down the rabbit hole


07/12

Getting ready


06/12

Impact of customer support


27/11

A lot has happened


19/11

It's ok to have bad days


08/09

My first productive week


17/07

Countdown & Commitment


08/07

Transition time


07/07

Our travel continues


06/07

Understanding Men & Women


05/04

The fear of the unknown


04/04

Hello World (literally)


01/03

Almost being scammed


09/02

Our next chapter


02/02

2019

Forced to try something new


10/10

I am not good at ...


29/09

ContextLabel 1.6.0


08/05

2018

I'm not on LinkedIn


24/12

Don't be right, be open


22/12

Healthy Lifestyle


30/09

2016

Hill88


08/08